The following column linked to this study to support the claim 3-5% of people with mental illness are likely to commit a crime. That’s the only part of the mental illness community social libs and fiscal cons support spending tax money to treat. Everyone else ‘must’ pay, not seek ‘other peoples’ money’ (taxes) in financial aid. Instead 95-97% of people *must* (sarcasm alert) help themselves with individual empowerment, mindfulness and self advocate/consumer-survivor operated community organizations. People *should* (sarcasm alert) have freedom to succeed or fail, where failure means to live a descent into deeper poverty. At least the free sovereign individual is participating in free markets living under a republican form of government, without democracy, to build a nation around. (End sarcasm alert)
In this study 29% of family murders and 7% of murders are related to SMI and that’s the only population the Manhattan Institute-paid fellow prescribes as worthy of public spending. Any other needs should be privatized. Instead of surveillance and compulsion leading to involuntary in-patient commitment or involuntary (assisted) outpatient treatment elected legislators at local, state and federal levels should put the money into expanding benefits counseling to help patients and families struggling to navigate confusing state and local systems of care (paid for with federal funds to states) before people deteriorate into a crisis.
Fuller Torrey-founder of TAC, that released the paper DJ Jaffe cites, support of forced commitment or outpatient treatment that for-profit insurance is too greedy to pay for unless required joins the Manhattan Institute from a more fiscally liberal or economically-populist viewpoint. Get the most needy helped even if it costs more in local, state or federal taxes to pay for the help that individuals in need cannot pay for.
Fuller Torrey did call out insurer Bill McGuire of United Health Care greed
Fuller Torrey in this 1998 "Brain Storm" article (reprinted from the Washington D.C. City Paper) called out managed care 'one size fits all for efficiency for profit' practice of medicine and even United Health Care CEO Bill McGuire’s $6.1 million 1 year ($1 Billion in UHC CEO career) salary.
Over the course of two hours, Torrey rails against federal funding schemes for mental health care and attacks civil liberties lawyers for preventing sick people from getting well. He takes some potshots at John Mack, the Harvard psychiatrist who bills insurance companies for psychotherapy treatment for people who've been abducted by aliens. He skewers "mangled care" companies for paying CEOs multimillion-dollar salaries at the same time that they deprive the mentally ill of treatment. After noting that in 1994 William McGuire, CEO of United Healthcare, received $6.1 million in compensation, Torrey says, "If any of you think William McGuire is going to give back $1 million to open a clubhouse [a successful day program for the mentally ill], see me afterward and I'll give you a prescription for Haldol."
The Manhattan Institute elevated DJ Jaffe's views into the WaPo
because the piece didn’t call out for-profit insurance company greed because the fellowship grantor Manhattan Institute (employer of D.J. Jaffe for purposes of pay for writing the column) has a mission that is too-individual supremacist and supportive of small government to call to improve the commons paid for by all levels of government.
The books P.C. M.D., "SHAM How the Self-Help and Actualization Movement Made America Helpless" described here try to show that helping people ration themselves out of seeking help for less acute, or chronic, problems with mindfulness is a failure.
Instead of shifting costs for 95-97% of people with MI symptoms who may be dually-diagnosed with Developmental Disability without Intellectual Disability, or prevent 29% of family murders and 7% of all murders help the person in desperate need before they harm without surveillance and stigma. Expand public discourse and medical classification concept of dual diagnosis beyond substance abuse to DD without ID, formerly mental retardation before Rosa’s Law. Expand availability of help with independent living issues, that will require ‘someone else’s money,’ at all government levels with a policy ERPO (extreme risk protection order AKA a 'red flag') to build an electoral imperative (people demand their 'electeds' authorize spending in budgets) to increase and reprogram (divert from what hasn't worked to what works) spending on public mental health programs.
Even socially-liberal California isn't yet fiscally-liberal or economically-populist enough
Williams said the ability of one-third of the legislature to block any form of taxation prevents those working to prevent gun violence from coming up with new solutions.
“One-third of the legislature blocks all forms of taxation, including ones that could make us safer, including ones that could provide revenue that is otherwise unavailable to make basic improvements in either our data basing, our investigations, our law enforcement,” Williams said. “I can tell you that most of our communities do not have adequate funding for law enforcement, and a tax on ammunition to fund that sort of investigation is a great idea and one that I would support.”
...
“We can’t get a two-thirds vote on almost any tax, and, frankly, there is not a single Republican vote I can think of in the legislature that would support any implementation of any limitations on firearms and certainly not imposing a tax.” Jackson said. “That’s double negative for the Republican party, a tax and then doing anything to challenge the gun lobby.”
to lessen individual surveillance to limit gun ownership rights or even tax bullets (ammunition) to increase state spending on LTSS in HCBS.
How about a budget ERPO, or 'red flag' fiscal policy, to spend more, not cut and shift to individuals directly and indirectly-affected, spending for voluntary services where people live? In 2002 a county Blue Ribbon Commission documented similar problems after CPC Health, owner-operator of Chestnut Lodge, closed ultimately becoming more luxury housing in 15 years. No follow up on what happened to former patients
who may or may not have found adequate individual help from its replacement was done. Policies to maintain confidentiality conceal inequity and inequality after austerity. Another commission renewed study of the Mobile Crisis Teams and 24-7 walk-in centers paid for by the public mental health system and released a 2019 Annual Report. One of the last sentences in the 2019 Annual Report is not hopeful, by the emphasis on relationship between MI and substance use and addiction, for improving LTSS in HCBS for Marylanders with SPMI (severe persistent mental illness) dually-diagnosed with DD without ID such as autism spectrum disorder without intellectual disability.
It is the hope of the Commission that by addressing the critical issue of mental and behavioral
health, including its relationship to substance use disorder and the opioid epidemic, that the State will be able to better
deliver services to its most vulnerable citizens, improve outcomes, and save lives.